Just start, if it takes time, it will take time
In all the years at Hetzner I never had a broken HDD. Maybe I shouldn't have said that .. nock nock nock.
The problem is just this one hdd-model... it's a mess!
The first hdd broke after one year (sdb). Fortunately, this one was replaced immediately as just one week later sda said goodbye. While sdb was replaced by a new hdd, sda got exchanged by a used one that had - at least as of smartctl-log - "a history". In other words: obvisously, this one was not 100% ok! Just three weeks later, it had to be replaced again - this time by a NEW Toshiba-drive. Works so far...